Home »

Journal Entry 1: “Mother Tongue”

“Mother Tongue” is about Amy Tan’s struggle to relate and empathize with her mother’s “broken” English. Since a young girl, the author had been exposed to the poor treatment her mother received for her English speaking skills like not being heard nor understood. This experience had negatively affected Tan into thinking that her mother was less than because of her “low” English level. As a result Tan says that her mother’s capabilities stunted her personal growth in the English language leading to low IQ and SAT scores because “a person’s developing language skills are more influenced by peers.” As Tan grew into a strong writer she came to understand that her mother isn’t less than because her English doesn’t suit societal norms. 

      I can strongly relate to Amy Tan because I too had these feelings with my mother. My mother would try to speak English, but always encountered someone who just couldn’t get passed her Spanish accent, so she’d call on me to translate her concerns; at parent teacher conferences, doctor’s appointments, etc. As I got older I realized my mother had been properly addressing herself, but the confused stares from others stunted her confidence and only kept her further away from the language. Through my personal experiences with opposing cultural prospectives when it comes to the English language I’ve learned to appreciate everyone’s varying English stages. The differences signify strength and courage because It’s difficult to assimilate to a country where your mother tongue is seen as less than. Despite the varying accents and sentence structures, being able to communicate in a new language needs to be applauded not dismissed. 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. Your statement of “being able to communicate in a new language needs to be applauded not dismissed,” is very empowering. This was highly enlightening as I had not thought to encourage others of their choice to strengthen a certain language and to appreciate their stages of learning a new language. It definitely is discouraging to find those who are above me in a certain language, and exists a sense of shame. Not only does acting superior make one feel shameful of not having ascertained a certain level of proficiency in a language, but I also find false humility to create a culture of sub-conscious shame, a shame not easily recognized or noticed which demotivates me to progress further in those specific languages. Thank you for your perspective.

  2. It is a great thing to be able to understand the emotions the author has in your life experiences. Often times and not just in the U.S might I add, people struggling to speak the common language of said country, are seen as those with limited thinking and lack emotional responses. As a society, I truly believe we need to be willing to take the time to understand how we each feel regardless of background an language. I never had this experience growing up since I started elementary school here however, my assimilation process drove me further from where I came from

Comments are closed.

Spam prevention powered by Akismet

Skip to toolbar